Customer Reviews & Moderation Policy

1. Purpose

We publish customer reviews to provide a transparent and accurate reflection of customer experiences. We are committed to complying with UK consumer protection law, including the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC Act).

We publish all genuine customer reviews, whether positive or negative. Reviews may be moderated for authenticity, relevance, and compliance with our policy.

2. What Reviews We Accept

We welcome reviews about:

  • Product quality and performance
  • Delivery
  • Customer service and aftercare

3. How Reviews Are Displayed

To improve clarity and fairness:

  • Reviews may be categorised (e.g. “Product”, “Delivery”, “Customer Service”)
  • Product ratings may be calculated only from relevant product reviews, where clearly explained

We do this to ensure reviews remain relevant and not misleading to customers.

4. When We May Remove or Reject Reviews

We only remove reviews where there is a clear and justified reason. These include:

Fake or Non-Genuine Reviews

  • Reviews not based on a real customer experience
  • Reviews submitted by bots or third parties
  • Reviews claiming product use where no use has occurred

 

Not Based on Actual Product Experience

We may remove or reclassify reviews where:

  • The reviewer explicitly states they have not used the product, but rates it as if they have

However:

  • Reviews about delivery before use will still be allowed (but may be categorised separately)

Irrelevant or Misplaced Reviews

We may remove or relocate reviews that:

  • Are clearly about a different product
  • Are unrelated to any purchase or customer experience

Where possible, these will be reassigned rather than deleted.

Unlawful or Policy-Breaching Content

We may remove reviews containing:

  • Offensive, abusive, or defamatory language
  • Personal data or sensitive information
  • Spam or promotional content

5. What We Do NOT Do

To comply with the DMCC Act, we do not:

  • Remove or hide genuine negative reviews
  • Cherry-pick positive reviews or suppress negative ones
  • Prevent customers from leaving honest feedback

6. Transparency

We:

  • Apply moderation rules equally to all reviews (positive and negative)
  • Clearly explain how ratings are calculated
  • Disclose if any reviews are incentivised

7. Handling Disputes

If a customer believes their review was wrongly removed:

  • They can contact us at: info@orchardtoys.com
  • We will review the decision and respond promptly

8. Ongoing Monitoring

We maintain systems to:

  • Identify and remove fake or misleading reviews
  • Ensure compliance with CMA guidance and UK law